An explication of a student essay in critical analysis. Here we will be doing (a particular kind of) critical examination of an expository/argumentative essay. That essay itself is doing a critical analysis of a piece of fictional narrative. (The writer of the essay has asked to 28/6/ · If you want to write a solid explication essay you need to develop the skills necessary to analyze a poem, play or short story. Your finished essay will demonstrate your ability to unfold the true meaning of the work and the author's motivation These mini-essays, typically a single page or less, require a close reading of the text to perform a proper interpretation of the quotation. The form of an explication essay requires a clear thesis presented in the introduction, a concise conclusion and supported analysis that interprets the meaning of the passage and the author’s intent
Critical Analysis Essay Examples for Students
An explication of a student essay in critical analysis. That essay itself is doing a critical analysis of a piece of fictional narrative. The writer of the essay has asked to remain anonymous, explication essay example, so we'll refer to her here as "Mary. This is the mark of explication. Its organization is passively determined by something outside it — the already-existing order of points in its subject. We could say that the organization of my explication is parasitic upon the organization of what it discusses.
This confronts her with three basic tasks. She has to produce and clarify and demonstrate a sub-thesis that states what precisely the point of view is.
The logical relationships among these three sub-tasks are what determine the organizational strategy of her essay, as a whole and within its respective modules, explication essay example. This structure is something she herself had to fashion, in response to the logical properties of the task at hand.
She had to assume the responsibility for actively making it. Before getting into the detailed explication provided below, read the essay itself all at one go, explication essay example. Ask yourself if you can detect what its thesis is and what the distinct lines of development are by which Mary clarifies and earns it.
When you are done, return here, and work through the frames carefully. Always read all the way through a box on the left-hand side before proceeding to the corresponding. comments in the right-hand column. When you turn your attention to the right-hand column, you'll make best use of the comments if you don't read them all at once, explication essay example, but instead work carefully back and forth, refreshing your sense of exactly what each comment points to before thinking your way through it.
When you come to the comment following the first paragraph, you'll need to have a fresh sense of what was said both in the original paragraph and in the comments upon it. Consult the original paragraph again after you've worked through the long summary comment following it.
This is rather dense stuff, so you may want to take a rest from time explication essay example time. It should reflect something particular about your particular angle on explication essay example specific subject, explication essay example. ç Right on. You get right to the point, and you are accurate about both the concept and the story in question.
That is: you show how it establishes a certain kind of game for the reader to play. In effect, this indicates the kinds of moves we can expect you to be undertaking, in the body of your essay, as you unpack and back up your thesis. ç At the climax of your introduction you sharpen your thesis still further.
We have an exact idea of what you will be driving at through the body of your essay. ç Here you give a restatement of your thesis, but you do it in a way that advances it beyond mere repetition. ç You then back this up with an example.
ç You proceed to give an additional example. This one requires to be developed in steps, and you undertake each.
You promise something more and anchor it in a specific fact. Then you provide a citation to anchor that characterization in turn. ç Now you set out to give still a third example. This one requires still a different strategy of development than either of the first two. Your second sentence in this section ups the ante, since it raises the anxiety in us that you may be wandering from the point or that we may not be getting your drift.
This drives us forward to look for clues as to how this might be on-point after all, explication essay example. ç You show us what ties all these together a disposition to feel envy. ç And then you show how this envy in turn can be turned to account on behalf of the thesis you started out the paragraph with.
When we think back explication essay example the paragraph as a whole, three things stand out: It is unified. It is richly developed, explication essay example. It is coherent. Or will she drive over the cliff? Part of what serves this coherence is a pleasing overall strategy of deployment of the evidence that she has discovered she is able to give. We notice that she begins with the shortest subtask to get through, then takes up the next longest, and concludes with the one that takes the most elaboration to pull off.
Note, by the way, that there are some points here that Mary could have explicitly incorporated into her analysis. We might ask ourselves: was Mary really consciously aware of all this while she was writing?
She may well have been, explication essay example. This is a pretty deft piece explication essay example writing, and there's no reason we shouldn't suppose that the author of it was not deliberately working with these factors in mind. But it is also possible that she was acting on the kind of tacit "feel" that we develop with experience. The organizational strategy works for any reader who is responding to the overall structure of the paragraph as a whole, and it's hard to imagine a writer being able to craft a paragraph like this without working from a sense of how the entire paragraph unrolls.
Such a reader doesn't need to reflectively say to himself the points I made in the paragraph before last. The "feel" of the paragraph can communicate those ideas to us "tacitly. But it is crucial that we be the kind of reader that can register such a explication essay example small to large, explication essay example, obvious to subtle in the deployment of successive pieces of evidence on behalf of a claim.
If we are the kind of reader who can only attend to one thing at a time, we are not yet ready even to register structure. Until we are, we can't appreciate the organizational merits of a well-written piece. Worse yet, we can't design rational and effective organizational structures for our own discourse. We won't be able to gradually shape our initial drafts into something cogent and insightful. We'll always end up with more or less the same jumble of claims with which we began.
More on this later on. At this point in the story the reader still does not know much about the protagonist, except that she is a lonely voyeur. She is as old as explication essay example other park-goers, her fur is a pitiful necklet, and she foregoes her usual Sunday slice of honeycake. The tears are obviously her own. ç This turns out to be an effective transition. And in each node between which the connection explication essay example the writer provides the concrete details that establish her specific point.
ç [Minor explication essay example of mechanics: when giving a parenthetic page reference for textual citation presented in quotation marks, the parenthetical material goes outside the terminal quotation mark, explication essay example.
ç The writer now shifts to still another explication essay example of development: you spell out specific implications of what you have established. She began by spelling out specific facts that made for that point itself. Work Cited. Mansfield, Katherine. Kennedy and Dana Gioia. New York: Longman, My comments on Mary's essay should drive home the point that "critical attention" in our sense of the term is not a matter of looking for flaws.
It is rather a matter of picking out what features of something are responsible for its working the way it does. If something is not working well, we come to notice that, explication essay example, too, of course, explication essay example.
But it is critical examination that is explication essay example for if we are to appreciate a job well done. By "appreciate" here I mean something more than just "experience a feeling of approval.
Let's finish up by using what we've seen here to drive home some important distinctions, explication essay example. The term "critical analysis" is often used to refer to the common denominator between what Mary has done in her essay and what I have been doing upon it. In both case the writer is picking out what works in some way and explaining why it works that way and why its doing so is important.
But among ourselves we will foster clarity on an important point if we reserve the explication essay example "critical analysis" to refer to the sort of thing that Mary has been up to, and use some other term to refer to the kind of thing you have just seen me do.
For what I've been doing, the term " explication " comes to mind, and we'll use it for that explication essay example. When we want to refer to the common denominator, we'll use the term "critical examination" or "critical attention" or simply " criticism ", explication essay example.
But there is more than one distinction between what I've been doing and what Mary has been doing. A difference otherwise worth noting but not the one I'm suggesting we use this terminological practice to highlight has to do with the object subjected to critical examination.
In the one case, what was analyzed was a piece of narration it happened to be fictional. In the other, explication essay example, what was under commentary happened to be an essay. These differences are important, but they are like the difference between bringing critical attention to bear on a political decision and bringing it to bear upon a rat's brain, or a painting, or a marketing strategy. In each case the things it makes sense to notice -- to select for attention -- and the kinds explication essay example functions one wants to explain are obviously different, explication essay example.
That's why we need some experience in each domain if we are to do competent critical thinking about the objects in those domains. It is the logical explication essay example among these three sub-tasks that determine the organizational strategy of Mary's essay, both as a whole and within its respective modules. My overall structure thus has no inherent logic of its own.
Explication essay example that would not have been a proper means to adopt for the end in view. She would have been compelled either to ignore the explication essay example topic altogether, or continually to be at cross-purposes with it.
She would be trying to cut boards with a hammer or to drive nails with a saw. Am I then doing the wrong thing in providing an explication instead of an essay in critical analysis?
Why is that? What has that got to do with why you are reading this, which is to learn something about writing? We can trouble-shoot any emerging draft we are writing so as to figure out how to make it work better — to bring it explication essay example the next stage, to explication essay example it into a superior draft, explication essay example.
How to Write an Explication
, time: 14:193 Strong Argumentative Essay Examples, Analyzed
28/6/ · If you want to write a solid explication essay you need to develop the skills necessary to analyze a poem, play or short story. Your finished essay will demonstrate your ability to unfold the true meaning of the work and the author's motivation An explication of a student essay in critical analysis. Here we will be doing (a particular kind of) critical examination of an expository/argumentative essay. That essay itself is doing a critical analysis of a piece of fictional narrative. (The writer of the essay has asked to [The poem for explication is Robert Graves' "Counting the Beats": the explication follows Graves' poem.] Counting the Beats. Robert Graves ( – ) You, love, and I, (He whispers) you and I, And if no more than only you and I. What care you or I? Counting the bests, Counting the slow heart beats, The bleeding to death of time in slow heart beats
No comments:
Post a Comment